Port McNicoll

Your comprehensive guide to Port McNicoll, Tay, Ontario

SAFETY RATING

9.4 / 10

Very Low Crime Risk

View full crime analytics & trends →

Property Pulse

$715,145 Avg List

Solid inventory of detached family houses and townhomes.

Community Canvas

6,202,225 Residents

Rich tapestry of families, kids under 10, and professionals.

What You'll Love

Parks & Schools

High academic rankings and beautiful outdoor spaces.

Local Active Listings

Showing 1–38 of 38 properties

Show:
See All Listings
Residential Freehold for sale - 2 Bed, 1 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $369,000 (MLS# S13717290)
$369,000
2bd
1ba
Residential Freehold

817 Eighth Avenue, Tay

AFFORDABLE, MOVE-IN READY HOME IN A FAMILY-FRIENDLY COMMUNITY! Welcome to 817 Eighth Street in Port ...

MLS#: S13717290
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $79,969 (MLS# S13720338)
$79,969
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

548 Fifth Avenue Lot 86, Tay

Vacant land property spans 56x112 feet, providing a spacious area for designing and building a dream...

MLS#: S13720338
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $369,900 (MLS# S13706472)
$369,900
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

15 Swan Lane, Tay

A Rare and Exceptional Opportunity to Build Your Custom Dream Home on the Shores of Georgian Bay! Tu...

MLS#: S13706472
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 4 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $499,900 (MLS# S13701246)
$499,900
4bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

575 Simcoe Avenue, Tay

Check out this three bedroom bungalow backing onto greenspace in Port McNicoll. This home features g...

MLS#: S13701246
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $269,950 (MLS# S13702308)
$269,950
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

250 Kingfisher Avenue, Tay

You've just arrived in Paradise Point! This Seasonal cottage sits on a 60' x 146' lot in the heart o...

MLS#: S13702308
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 4 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $599,900 (MLS# S13667354)
$599,900
4bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

379 Wardell Street, Tay

Turn-Key Raised Bungalow On A 121 x 62 Ft Corner Lot With A Double Car Garage, a Generator, Plenty o...

MLS#: S13667354
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $679,900 (MLS# S13664574)
$679,900
3bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

376 Wardell Street, Tay

Welcome to 376 Wardell Street, a well-appointed raised bungalow situated on an impressive 121' x 124...

MLS#: S13664574
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 5 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $634,999 (MLS# S13655748)
Price Change
$634,999
5bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

363 Wardell Street, Tay

Welcome to this spacious and versatile 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom home, ideally situated on a quiet stree...

MLS#: S13655748
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 4 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $629,900 (MLS# S13644598)
$629,900
4bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

475 Athabaska Street, Tay

Welcome to this beautifully updated 3+1 bedroom bungalow, tucked away on a quiet, family-friendly ne...

MLS#: S13644598
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 1 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $479,900 (MLS# S13619686)
$479,900
3bd
1ba
Residential Freehold

317 Wardell Street, Tay

This newly renovated move-in ready home is a gem and ready to make it your own. Set on a large lot ...

MLS#: S13619686
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 5 Bed, 3 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $1,499,900 (MLS# S13580242)
$1,499,900
5bd
3ba
Residential Freehold

93 Silver Birch Crescent, Tay

Top 5 Reasons You Will Love This Home: 1) Set on the prestigious Paradise Point peninsula, this exce...

MLS#: S13580242
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $119,900 (MLS# S13572922)
$119,900
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

440 David Avenue, Tay

HERE'S WHY 440 DAVID AVENUE COULD BE YOUR NEXT MOVE: READY FOR YOUR VISION - Whether you're dreamin...

MLS#: S13572922
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $769,000 (MLS# S13564962)
$769,000
3bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

31 Earldom Boulevard, Tay

This custom built home has to be seen to be appreciated! JUST A SHORT STROLL TO THE SPECTACULAR PRI...

MLS#: S13564962
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 3 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $699,000 (MLS# S13558958)
$699,000
3bd
3ba
Residential Freehold

753 Fifth Avenue, Tay

Welcome to 753 Fifth Avenue, Tay-a fantastic opportunity to own a home that perfectly blends comfort...

MLS#: S13558958
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 2 Bed, 1 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $574,999 (MLS# S13544342)
Price Change
$574,999
2bd
1ba
Residential Freehold

14 Earldom Boulevard, Tay

Welcome to 14 Earldom Blvd, a beautifully renovated retreat just steps from the shores of Grandview ...

MLS#: S13544342
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 3 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $1,699,900 (MLS# S13537968)
$1,699,900
3bd
3ba
Residential Freehold

7 Dock Lane, Tay

Top 5 Reasons You Will Love This Home: 1) 2-storey home presenting a breathtaking waterfront with de...

MLS#: S13537968
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 4 Bed, 3 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $2,099,900 (MLS# S13510042)
$2,099,900
4bd
3ba
Residential Freehold

53 Dock Lane E 27, Tay

Welcome to Port McNicoll's best - kept secret, Exclusive community, serene peninsula on Georgian Bay...

MLS#: S13510042
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 3 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $999,000 (MLS# S13507024)
Price Change
$999,000
3bd
3ba
Residential Freehold

740 Midland Avenue, Tay

This 2023 unique custom built 2000 plus square feet bungalow, is located at the end of a quiet stree...

MLS#: S13507024
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 1 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $399,900 (MLS# S13498684)
Price Change
$399,900
3bd
1ba
Residential Freehold

9 EARLDOM Boulevard, Tay

Steps from Grandview Beach! This charming 3-season cottage offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy r...

MLS#: S13498684
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 1 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $139,900 (MLS# S13479340)
Price Change
$139,900
3bd
1ba
Residential Freehold

366 TALBOT Street, Tay

366 Talbot St is being offered strictly AS IS, WHERE IS, presenting an opportunity for buyers,renova...

MLS#: S13479340
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $649,900 (MLS# S13446202)
$649,900
3bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

3 Earldom Boulevard, Tay

NATURE AT YOUR DOORSTEP WITH GEORGIAN BAY JUST MOMENTS AWAY, A PRIVATE LANDSCAPED BACKYARD OASIS, & ...

MLS#: S13446202
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $129,900 (MLS# S13431850)
$129,900
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

564 Keewatin Avenue, Tay

Discover the perfect opportunity to build your dream home on this cleared and vacant building lot lo...

MLS#: S13431850
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $64,900 (MLS# S13431954)
$64,900
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

247 Dignard Avenue, Tay

Don't wait to invest! Invest and wait! This property currently has a "TT" designation. There is oppo...

MLS#: S13431954
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $115,000 (MLS# S13246468)
$115,000
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

401 McNicoll Street, Tay

Build Your Georgian Bay Dream. Discover the perfect setting for your future home or cottage on this ...

MLS#: S13246468
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $734,777 (MLS# S13233020)
$734,777
3bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

5 Easton Avenue, Tay

Tucked away on a quiet dead-end street, this charming 2+1 bedroom, 2-bathroom home blends comfort an...

MLS#: S13233020
For Sale
Residential Condo & Other for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $499,000 (MLS# S13200690)
Price Change
$499,000
0bd
0ba
Residential Condo & Other

19 Dock Lane, Tay

VTB AVAILABLE!!!!! An exceptional opportunity to build your dream waterfront retreat in one of South...

MLS#: S13200690
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 1 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $379,000 (MLS# S13127128)
Price Change
$379,000
3bd
1ba
Residential Freehold

183 Paradise Avenue, Tay

Welcome to 183 Paradise Avenue, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home located in the heart of beautiful Port M...

MLS#: S13127128
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 5 Bed, 4 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $1,799,900 (MLS# S13058134)
$1,799,900
5bd
4ba
Residential Freehold

81 Silver Birch Crescent, Tay

Set on approximately 120 feet of protected shoreline along Georgian Bay, this almost 3,000 sq ft rai...

MLS#: S13058134
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 2 Bed, 1 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $449,000 (MLS# S13059510)
$449,000
2bd
1ba
Residential Freehold

33 Gloucester Grove, Tay

Better Than Waterfront - All the Lifestyle, None of the Hassle. Enjoy the best of Georgian Bay livin...

MLS#: S13059510
For Sale
Residential Condo & Other for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $429,900 (MLS# S13016110)
$429,900
0bd
0ba
Residential Condo & Other

8 Swan Lane 56, Tay

Rare And Exceptional Opportunity To Build Your Custom Dream Home On The Shores Of Georgian Bay. Muni...

MLS#: S13016110
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 5 Bed, 2 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $674,777 (MLS# S12942832)
$674,777
5bd
2ba
Residential Freehold

480 Broderick Street, Tay

Welcome to 480 Broderick Street in Port McNicoll, ideally located on a quiet street just minutes fro...

MLS#: S12942832
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 3 Bed, 3 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $899,000 (MLS# S12902836)
Price Change
$899,000
3bd
3ba
Residential Freehold

2 Swan Lane, Tay

With its cupola, refined rooflines, and inviting front porch, this Cape Cod-inspired home makes a st...

MLS#: S12902836
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $129,900 (MLS# S12838214)
$129,900
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

503 Margaret Street, Tay

Turn your vision into reality on this great residential building lot in Port McNicoll, a charming wa...

MLS#: S12838214
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $99,900 (MLS# S12840252)
$99,900
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

230 Dignard Avenue, Tay

Grandview Beach Paradise Point...the name says it all! This stunning beach community is surrounded b...

MLS#: S12840252
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $69,900 (MLS# S12840426)
$69,900
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

505 Helen Duncan Street, Tay

Plan for a vibrant future in this lovely, quiet neighbourhood that sits in the centre of it all...th...

MLS#: S12840426
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 0 Bed, 0 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $415,000 (MLS# S12776874)
$415,000
0bd
0ba
Residential Freehold

55 Dock Lane 28, Tay

Welcome to Port McNicoll's best-kept secret - an exclusive, serene peninsula community on Georgian B...

MLS#: S12776874
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 4 Bed, 3 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $1,749,900 (MLS# S12462707)
Price Change
$1,749,900
4bd
3ba
Residential Freehold

18 Swan Lane, Tay

Welcome to picturesque Swan Lane, where luxury meets tranquility. It is located in a cul-de-sac, on ...

MLS#: S12462707
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 6 Bed, 3 Bath Home at Tay ON listed at $499,998 (MLS# S12334440)
Price Change
$499,998
6bd
3ba
Residential Freehold

856 Ney Avenue, Tay

Opportunity, Lifestyle, and Versatility all in one! Nestled in the charming waterfront community of...

MLS#: S12334440
For Sale
Home Buyer Edge

Benefits of Browsing Just Listed Properties in Port McNicoll, Tay

When searching for a home in Tay, timing is everything. Accessing fresh MLS® listings the moment they hit the market gives home buyers a critical competitive advantage in Ontario's fast-moving real estate market.

First-Mover Advantage

Be the first to view new listings in Tay within minutes of MLS® publication before competing buyers schedule viewings.

🤝

Motivated Sellers

Newly listed sellers are eager to receive serious offers and negotiate terms before setting offer dates.

🎯

Avoid Multiple Offers

Early inquiries allow proactive buyers to submit strong pre-emptive offers before bidding wars escalate prices.

📊

Accurate Price Valuation

Compare initial asking prices against recent Tay sold data to spot underpriced gems immediately.

Region Overview

Explore Port McNicoll

Port McNicoll, nestled on the stunning shores of Georgian Bay in Tay, Ontario, offers a truly unique and idyllic lifestyle. This charming village exudes a relaxed, small-town vibe, attracting nature lovers, artists, and those seeking a slower pace of life. The community is incredibly welcoming, with a strong sense of local pride and a tight-knit atmosphere. Expect stunning waterfront views, active boating, and a thriving arts scene, fueled by the annual Port McNicoll Music & Shakespeare Festival. While largely car-dependent, there are limited public transit options – primarily local bus services - but the area is incredibly walkable and bikeable. Housing options range from historic cottages and weathered Victorians – many boasting incredible lake views – to newer developments, including some waterfront condos and modest bungalows. If you’re looking for a community steeped in tradition and surrounded by breathtaking natural beauty, Port McNicoll is a fantastic place to consider for your next move. Finding affordable real estate in such a sought-after location is challenging, so be prepared for a competitive market searching for a waterfront home or cottage. Proximity to Collingwood and Wasaga Beach also offers weekend getaway opportunities for those seeking a bit more action. Keywords: Port McNicoll real estate, Tay Ontario, Georgian Bay, cottage country, waterfront homes, small town living, Ontario real estate.

💡 Insider Tips & Hidden Gems

Okay, let's dive into what the locals *really* recommend! Forget the main street tourist traps and head to the McNicoll General Store – it’s a Port McNicoll institution and the best place for local honey and baked goods. For stunning sunset views, walk the trail up to Port McNicoll Lighthouse; it’s a bit of a climb, but worth it. Seriously, the views are unbeatable. Don't miss Old Mill Park, a local favorite for picnics and letting the kids run around. If you’re a fisher, the pier is consistently producing trout and pickerel. Consider renting kayaks or paddleboards from Pete’s Rentals for an unforgettable experience on Georgian Bay. Ask locals for recommendations on the best blueberry patches – they’re fiercely protective of their secrets! Grab a bite at the McNicoll Tavern - they have a fantastic selection of local craft beers and hearty pub fare. And a hidden gem? The Little Theatre – a beautifully restored historic theatre that often hosts intimate performances. Finally, keep an eye out for the annual Logger's Festival (usually in September) – a truly authentic showcase of Ontario’s logging heritage. Parking can be challenging, especially during peak season, so arrive early!

Market Stats & Trends

Home Prices & Values in Tay

The asking price of homes for sale in Tay has increased 0.53% since last year, while the number of homes for sale has decreased 7.9%. See more Tay Home Prices & Values.

House
Median Asking Price
$1.1M
Townhouse
Median Asking Price
$763K
Condo
Median Asking Price
$544K

Find Real Estate & MLS® Listings in Tay

SousaSells.ca has the most thorough, up-to-date set of Tay real estate listings. Currently, Tay has 118 homes for sale, including 105 houses, 1 condos, and 0 townhouses listed for sale. The average price for all home types in Tay is $811K, which is up 4.8% compared to last year.

Tay is home to 5 unique neighbourhoods. With SousaSells.ca you'll be able to find the hottest Tay neighbourhoods, the best schools in the city, and evaluate nearby amenities. Check out the upcoming open houses in Tay to tour homes in person. Narrow down your home search to filter by price, bedrooms, size or search by our map of MLS® listings for Canada-wide real estate.

If you’re looking for rentals instead of properties for sale, SousaSells has a comprehensive set of 29 Tay rental listings, including 10 houses and 18 apartments/condos for rent.

MLS® Listing data for Tay is updated every 15 minutes to provide you the most-up-to-date home listings. Get in touch with one of our Tay real estate agents to get started on landing your dream home today.

Loading Interactive Map...

Median Age

The median age of residents in this area.

39.6 Yrs

Home Ownership

Percentage of owner-occupied households.

65% Owners
Neighborhood Safety Index

Neighborhood Safety & Crime Analytics

Port Mcnicoll, Tay

SAFETY RATING9.4 / 10
Low Incident Area
Total Annual Incidents35 incidents / yr
Average Per Month2.9 incidents / mo
Population BenchmarkArea Average residents
Personal Safety
Very Low

8 assaults (30.0/100k)

Property Security
Very Low

8 B&E (30.0/100k)

Auto Theft Risk
Low Risk

10 thefts (35.0/100k)

1-Year Trend
▼ 6%

Improving vs previous year

How Per-Capita Rate (Per 100,000 Residents) Is Calculated:

Formula: (Annual Occurrences / Population) × 100,000. This standard policing calculation normalizes incident frequencies across different population sizes, allowing accurate safety comparisons between quiet residential pockets and dense urban centres.

Source: Official Police Services ArcGIS Open Data
Halton & GTHA Police Network

Disclaimer: Crime and safety analytics are compiled from official municipal and regional police open data records for general consumer informational and demographic research purposes only. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and does not constitute a legal representation or guarantee of future safety.

People & Families

Demographics, age distribution, household size and makeup.

Age Demographics (Detailed Ranges)

Household Composition

One-person households
25%
Families with children
50%
Couples without children
24%
Other households
0%

Ethnic Origins

Chinese11%
English9%
Indian9%
Irish8%
Canadian7%

Local Schools

Ratings, ranking and classification of elementary and secondary schools.

Elementary Schools

No elementary schools data loaded for this city.

Secondary Schools

No secondary schools data loaded for this city.

Homes & Housing

Ownership rates, home structure distributions and listing prices.

Structural Home Types

Tenure (Ownership vs Rental)

Owner-Occupied65%
Rented35%

Real Estate Pulse

AVERAGE LIST PRICE$715,145
ACTIVE LISTINGS33 Listed32 for sale • 1 for lease